skip to main content

Pacifier Box

Rated 4.3 out of 5
68 Reviews|, Answered Questionsor
$
26.99
$
32.46
Free shipping & returns for Babylist orders $45+
1

Overview

Highlights

  • 6 pacifiers from Itzy Ritzy, nanobébé, BIBS, Dr. Brown’s, Chicco and AEIOU
  • BPA-free
  • Babylist exclusive

Description

When choosing a pacifier, the best pacifier is the one your baby will take.

Pacifiers can be total lifesavers for helping soothe your baby, but you can’t necessarily predict which one your baby will prefer. This means you’ll probably have to try a few different brands and styles to find the type your little one loves.

The Babylist Pacifier Box offers a helpful solution for new parents and their babies. The box comes with top pacifiers, so you and your baby can try them out to see which one they prefer.

Parent tip: Once you find the pacifier your baby likes, buy multiples to stash in different places around the house, your diaper bag, the car, grandma’s house. This way you’re never caught without your baby’s favorite soother.

Here are the pacifiers in the Babylist Pacifier Box:

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Pal Pacifier & Stuffed Animal

The Sweetie Pal pacifier and stuffed animal combo makes everyday soothing easier. Babies love the cuddly companion, plus it easily attaches to the handle of a Sweetie Soother making the pacifier easy to locate.

nanobébé Flexy Pacifier

This silicone pacifier is soft yet durable, with an ergonomic design and a unique nipple shape that helps promote healthy mouth development. The design also helps discourage nipple confusion, making it good for breastfed babies.

BIBS Colour Pacifier

Made in Denmark, this wide-shield pacifier features a symmetrical flat drop-shaped nipple that promotes a tongue placement and sucking technique. The shield is also made of 100% food-grade material.

Dr. Brown’s One-Piece Silicone Pacifier

This one-piece design is made from soft, 100% medical-grade silicone. If you use Dr. Brown’s bottles, the nipples are shaped the same to help avoid nipple confusion.

Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Mini Orthodontic Pacifier

Made in Italy, this option isn’t just for pacifying, it’s also developed for comfort, breathing and orthodontic benefits. Designed for 0-2 months, the pacifier actively supports baby’s breathing by positioning their tongue forward, which helps to maintain an open airway.

AEIOU Silicone Pacifier

This simple one-piece soother is from 100% food-grade silicone with two large vents for airflow.

What we  about it

A giftable collection of favorite pacifiers that lets new parents—and their babies—see which ones they like best.

Details

  • 10” x 7” x 3”; approx 1 lb

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Pal Pacifier & Stuffed Animal

  • Age: 0+
  • Character: Llama
  • Sweetie Pal: Handmade of velour (5”x 8”)
  • Included pacifier: 100% food-grade silicone
  • Pacifier includes two large vent holes for added safety
  • To clean Sweetie Pal: Detach and machine wash and line dry
  • To clean pacifier: Before first use, place pacifier in boiling water for 5 mins; allow to cool and squeeze out any water

nanobébé Flexy Pacifier

  • Age: 0-3 months
  • Color: Sage
  • Silicone nipple
  • BPA and phthalate free
  • Hand wash with warm water

BIBS Colour Pacifier

  • Age: 0+
  • Shield: Food-grade PP
  • Nipple: Natural rubber latex
  • 100% free from BPA, PVC and phthalates
  • Sterilize before use
  • To clean: Pour boiling water over pacifier in a bowl; let soak 5 minutes and then dry
  • Not dishwasher safe

Dr. Brown’s One-Piece Silicone Pacifier

  • Age: 0-6 months
  • Color: Mint
  • 100% medical-grade silicone
  • Dishwasher safe
  • BPA free

Chicco PhysioForma Silicone Mini Orthodontic Pacifier

  • Age: 0-2 months
  • Color: Clear
  • Extra-light and ultra-small shield
  • Super-soft, skin-like textured nipple to promote more comfort and less slip
  • Ventilation holes promote air circulation
  • One-piece silicone construction
  • BPA and latex free
  • Reusable, sterilizing carry case included; microwave to sterilize pacifiers in just three minutes

AEIOU Silicone Pacifier

  • Age: 0 months+
  • Made from 100% food-grade silicone
  • Does not contain PVC, BPA, phthalates or other toxic materials
  • Before use: Wash and inspect product for defects
  • To clean: Hand wash and place pacifier in boiling water for up to 2 minutes prior to initial use; hand wash regularly with hot, soapy water, rinse well and dry thoroughly
  • Do not use microwave to sterilize product
  • Dishwasher and sterilizer safe
  • Made in China

  • Please note: items may differ slightly from photos (like the color, packaging or size), but descriptions are accurate

Q&A

Have a question? Ask an expert.Have a question about this? Ask an expert.
Start typing and see existing answers.

Customer reviews

68 Ratings
4.3out of 5
68 Ratings

Rated 5 stars by 68% of reviewers

Rated 4 stars by 13% of reviewers

Rated 3 stars by 4% of reviewers

Rated 2 stars by 9% of reviewers

Rated 1 star by 6% of reviewers

1-10 of 68 Reviews
Nice to be able to try lots at once. We ended up going with the Dr. Browns one!
Nov 7, 2025
Was this helpful?
Lots of options, but didn’t end up using or liking half of them. They don’t represent a nipple or bottle very well.
Jul 15, 2025
Was this helpful?
Rated 1 out of 5
Don’t recommend it
Too big for newborn. None of them worked out for me.
Jun 12, 2025
Was this helpful?
Rated 3 out of 5
Great concept
Great concept, but 3 out of 6 of these I had already received as free gifts from creating a registry. I ended up buying other pacifiers to try because I wanted to make sure to baby got to try them all.
May 22, 2025
Was this helpful?
All of these binky shapes will mess your kids teeth up. MAM is the only thing my kids have ever accepted. This isn't a bad idea, the execution is just poor with their selection of all basically the same shape binky.
Jan 13, 2025
Was this helpful?
Rated 5 out of 5
Nice to try
Easy one and done option for sampling pacifiers. Every baby has different preferences. My daughter only took the Bibs from this box. I would have given up and assumed she wouldn’t ever take one if it wasn’t for having a variety readily available for her to try. I’ll happily give the others away and buy more of her favorite now.
Jan 10, 2025
Was this helpful?
Nice variety to try but was missing the Dr. browns pacifier.
Dec 21, 2024
Was this helpful?
Rated 5 out of 5
BUY THIS!!
I am so glad I bought this. I was overwhelmed trying to decide. Our little one tried each one until we found the one for her. This saved us so much money! Do yourself a favor - grab it!
Oct 28, 2024
Was this helpful?
A great box for your registry. My baby spit out 4/5 of these and loved one of them. Has started to take others as she gets older but this was a great way to try different kinds.
Oct 2, 2024
Was this helpful?
So nice to have a variety to have your baby try prior to buying more pacifiers!
Aug 5, 2024
Was this helpful?