Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial: I Tested Both Trendy Carriers
Which baby carrier is better for your lifestyle? We compare these top picks to help you decide.
By
One of the most common questions new parents ask about the Artipoppe Zeitgeist is: Is it worth the splurge? With its luxe fabrics, artisanal craftsmanship and celebrity following, the Zeitgeist has earned a cult status. But at a much lower price point, the WildBird Aerial has emerged as a popular, stylish contender.
If you're deciding between the Artipoppe Zeitgeist and the WildBird Aerial carrier, you're already looking at two babywearing MVPs. As a Babylist editor and mom of two, I’ve tested a wide range of carriers over the years—including these two—so I could compare how they truly perform. Both support multiple carry positions, grow with your baby from newborn to toddler and look good doing it. But depending on your lifestyle, personal preferences and budget, one may be a better fit than the other.
Here's how these two structured baby carriers compare so you can decide which one might be the best fit for you.
Ease of Use: Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial
I found both carriers pretty easy to learn, though the Zeitgeist felt more intuitive right away.
The Zeitgeist’s waistband buckles with no extra looping or folding, making it a true throw-on-and-go option. The shoulder straps criss-cross at the back and buckle under your arms, and once you’ve done it once or twice, the routine feels seamless. Adjusting the fit is straightforward and the straps glide smoothly when tightening—something especially helpful when you're solo and in a hurry.
The Aerial, while also beginner-friendly, includes a few extra steps. You’ll need to thread the waistband strap through a loop before buckling—an easy task, but it does add a moment of setup. Getting the shoulder straps tight enough felt a little awkward at first and wasn’t quite as fluid as the Zeitgeist. That said, the strap configuration is similar: they criss-cross at the back and buckle at the sides, and once you're used to the setup, it's easy to replicate.
For newborns, the Aerial’s apron-style panel needs to be folded down to adjust the seat height properly. This creates a more customized fit for smaller babies (as long as they meet the minimum weight limit), but does require some added know-how. The Zeitgeist doesn’t require seat-height folding or a newborn insert; its panel naturally supports a newborn when worn snug and high on your chest and adjusts seamlessly as baby grows, which makes it easier to use across stages.
The Artipoppe Zeitgeist and WildBird Aerial buckle comparison photo. (Photo: Briana Engelbrecht, Babylist Associate Editor)
Portability is another factor that plays into ease of use. Both carriers are lightweight and travel-friendly. The Zeitgeist’s fabric is thinner and sleeker, while the Aerial’s linen feels more structured. The Zeitgeist is slightly harder to fold compactly due to its wide front panel, but both will still fit in a roomy diaper bag or under a stroller.
Both brands offer solid support for new users. WildBird has a downloadable PDF user manual and offers free virtual consults to help parents get the perfect fit. Artipoppe has a full video library with tutorials for different carry positions and dedicated guidance for newborns.
Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial Ease of Use: How They Compare
Both carriers are easy to use once you get the hang of them, but the Zeitgeist has a slight edge for its ultra-intuitive design and fewer setup steps.
Comfort: Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial
Comfort is one of the most important aspects of a baby carrier, especially if you’ll be wearing it for extended periods. Thankfully, both carriers are up to the task.
Each has padded shoulder straps that don’t dig in, but the Zeitgeist’s feel a bit more pillowy. Some parents who’ve used both say the Aerial’s straps can dig in slightly after wearing a heavier baby for a longer time.
The Zeitgeist’s waistband is wide and stiff—almost like it has a layer of thick cardstock inside—which provides excellent support but can feel a little bulky or uncomfortable when sitting down. The Aerial’s waistband is narrower and padded in front. While most colorways are soft out of the box, some, like the “Giggle” pattern shown here, feel stiffer and may take a bit of breaking in.
The Artipoppe Zeitgeist's soft, padded straps. (Photo: Stormie Fraser, Babylist Freelance Photo Editor)
Both carriers are adjustable and size-inclusive, allowing them to work for all different body types, but there are some differences:
Zeitgeist is one size fits all.
WildBird Aerial comes in two size ranges:
Small (XS–XL): fits waists 24"–41"
Large (L–4XL): fits waists 35"–53.3"
While the Aerial’s dual sizing offers a more tailored fit, it can make it trickier to share between caregivers who wear different sizes. If that’s part of your plan, the one-size Zeitgeist may be easier to swap back and forth.
Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial Comfort: How They Compare
Each of these picks is super comfortable, whether you’re wearing your baby around the house or out and about. For the long term, most parents agree that the Zeitgeist has a slight leg up, likely due to the wider waistband that helps really get baby’s weight evenly distributed on the body so there aren’t any pressure points.
The Artioppe Zeitgeist carrier in Monogamy Maiden. (Photo: Stormie Fraser, Babylist Freelance Photo Editor)
The WildBird Aerial carrier in Sparrow. (Photo: Jaclyn Bergmann, Babylist Associate Art Director)
Style: Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial
The Zeitgeist is an iconic carrier that’s taken the world by storm. It’s a go-to for celebrity parents and social media influencers, and it’s not hard to see why. Artipoppe carriers come in luxe fabrics—think cashmere blends, organic cotton and even silk—and are available in bold, fashion-forward prints as well as rich solids. It feels like a designer accessory, and for many parents, it is. The Zeitgeist often turns heads and adds a serious dose of style to even the most casual outfits.
The Aerial is also undeniably stylish. WildBird has long been known for their beautiful, neutral ring slings, and they’ve carried that same aesthetic into the Aerial. It’s made from soft, breathable linen and comes in a rotating mix of earth tones, pastels and seasonal patterns. The brand regularly drops limited-edition colorways that feel fresh but still timeless. One subtle but notable detail: the Aerial’s webbing is color-matched or coordinating, while the Zeitgeist’s straps remain black across all colorways—something to consider if strap color matters to your overall look.
The Artipoppe Zeitgeist carrier in Monogamy Maiden and the WildBird Aerial carrier in Giggle. (Photo: Briana Engelbrecht, Babylist Associate Editor)
Both of these carriers are beautifully made and reflect a strong sense of design. Whether you prefer bold and luxurious or minimal and modern, there's a colorway for everyone.
Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial Style: How They Compare
The Zeitgeist and Aerial each make a strong style statement—but in different ways. If you want something iconic, editorial and luxe, the Zeitgeist is your match. If your vibe leans soft, neutral and natural, the Aerial also delivers style, without shouting.
Either way, you’re the one wearing it—why not wear something that reflects your personal style and makes you feel good? Let the vibes lead you.
Value: Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial
The most obvious difference between these two carriers is the price—and it’s a big one.
The WildBird Aerial is the more budget-friendly option, ranging from $178 to just under $230, depending on the fabric and colorway. While that price point still places it in the premium tier compared to many mainstream carriers, it’s significantly more affordable than the Artipoppe Zeitgeist, which starts around $370 and can run into the thousands for limited-edition styles or luxe materials like silk, velvet or wool blends.
If price is a major factor in your decision, the Aerial clearly wins in affordability. That said, both brands position themselves as premium babywearing experiences, so even at the lower end, the Aerial is still an investment.
A few more things to consider:
When it comes to value beyond the price tag, there are a few more things to keep in mind:
Wearability & Longevity: One key difference is that the Aerial is limited to inward-facing front carry only, while the Zeitgeist offers both front and back carry options, giving more ways to babywear as your little one grows. For parents looking to babywear beyond the infant stage or on hikes or travel, this versatility may tip the scale.
Quality & Craftsmanship: Both carriers are beautifully made with high-quality materials. Artipoppe takes things a step further with its handcrafted, artisan approach, which is reflected in the price. WildBird, while machine-sewn, still puts a strong emphasis on sustainability and quality textiles, especially their signature breathable linen.
Registry Tip: If you’ve got your eye on one of the higher-end colorways (especially from Artipoppe), don’t forget to enable group gifting on your registry. Big-ticket items like carriers are perfect for friends and family to chip in on.
Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial Value: How They Compare
If you’re looking for a luxe, long-term investment piece with multiple carry positions and artisan quality, the Zeitgeist delivers, though at a steep price. If budget is your top priority but you still want comfort, beauty and thoughtful design, the Aerial is a fantastic, more affordable alternative that doesn’t skimp on quality.
The Bottom Line: Artipoppe Zeitgeist vs. WildBird Aerial
Both the Artipoppe Zeitgeist and the WildBird Aerial are beautiful, thoughtfully designed baby carriers—but they shine in different ways depending on what matters most to you.
The Artipoppe Zeitgeist is a luxe, fashion-forward carrier that feels as comfortable as it looks. With its sleek design, high-end fabrics and ability to carry in both front and back positions, it’s ideal for parents who want a standout style and are willing to invest in something that doubles as a statement piece. Just keep in mind only some of the styles are machine washable (on a delicate cycle), so a little extra care is required.
The WildBird Aerial, on the other hand, is lightweight, compact and easy to clean—machine washable for the win. Its soft, breathable linen fabric makes it a great pick for warm weather or active days out and its neutral aesthetic fits right into a minimalist gear setup. While it doesn’t offer a back carry option, it’s still a highly comfortable and supportive choice, especially for everyday babywearing.
Whether you’re drawn to bold style or practical simplicity, you really can’t go wrong—just choose the one that fits your lifestyle (and your budget) best.
