skip to main content
The Best Breast Pump for Every Budget
January 31, 2024

The Best Breast Pump for Every Budget

Babylist editors love baby gear and independently curate their favorite products to share with you. If you buy something through links on our site, Babylist may earn a commission.
Pinterest logo.
The Best Breast Pump for Every Budget.
The Best Breast Pump for Every Budget

Thanks to the Affordable Care Act, it’s now possible to get a breast pump covered for free under your insurance (and Babylist makes it even easier to get your pump). But what if you don’t have insurance or your plan doesn’t cover the pump that you want? Or if you’re a frequent pumper who’s been eying up the latest and greatest when it comes to breast pumps?

Many pumping parents end up purchasing a breast pump for one reason or another or adding to their pumping arsenal with a wearable breast pump. Luckily there are lots of great options—breast pumps are available in every price range from as low as $15 to upwards of $500. Each price range offers different types of pumps with various features, capabilities and conveniences.

Here’s what to expect in every price range and the best breast pump for your budget.

How We Chose Our Best Breast Pumps by Budget

  • We analyzed results from Babylist’s Best Baby Products survey, which polled 6,000 Babylist users and asked them to share the baby products they love the most and why.
  • We utilized insight from the Babylist editorial team, including Gear Editor Jen LaBracio, an expert in the baby space for over six years and a mom of two who has written hundreds of baby gear guides and personally researched and tested hundreds of baby products, including many breast pumps across various price ranges.
  • We reviewed customer reviews from hundreds of real Babylist parents.

The Best Breast Pumps Under $50

What you’ll get at this price point:

  • Mostly manual breast pumps; hand-operated and non-electric
  • Single breast pumps—can only pump one breast at a time

These breast pumps work best if you’re:

  • An occasional pumper
  • Looking for a quick, easy way to manage oversupply or collect milk from one breast while your baby nurses on the other
  • Need a compact, easy-to-use pump for expressing milk on the go (think a night out with friends or a long car ride when you don’t have access to an outlet)
  • Uses natural suction; no manual pumping or electrical outlet needed
  • Made from 100% food-grade silicone
  • Compact and easily portable

Probably the easiest-to-use breast pump around, many parents swear by the Haakaa. Its one-piece design uses natural suction to express milk; all you need to do is squeeze it, attach it to your breast and let it do the rest. It’s great for catching milk from letdown, collecting milk from one breast while your baby is nursing on the other or stashing in your diaper bag or purse for pumping on the go. Other brands make similarly affordable silicone collection pumps; check out the Lansinoh Silicone Breastmilk Collector, the Medela Silicone Breast Milk Collector and the Dr. Brown’s Silicone One-Piece Breast Pump for other options.

  • Fits inside your bra
  • Uses natural suction to express milk

Similar to Haakaa’s silicone manual pump, the Boon Trove works with natural suction—but the rounded shape lets you slip this pump right inside of your bra, making it a truly wearable option. (Some pumping parents prefer this as it prevents your baby from being able to kick it off while nursing.) It holds three ounces of milk and BPA free and dishwasher safe.

  • Hand-powered
  • Compatible with multiple breast shield sizes
  • Bottle stand helps stop spills

The Medela Harmony is one of the most popular manual breast pumps. It’s operated by hand and is really easy to use and to store, which makes it a great choice if you’re looking for an affordable manual pump.

  • Large, ergonomic handle makes manual pumping less tiring
  • Rubber massage cushion on the breast flange

Pumping by hand can get tiring, so we appreciate the oversized, ergonomic handle on this manual pump that makes things a little easier. (You can even lean back while using this hand pump, thanks to its unique design.) The breast flange features five rubber massage cushions that mimic the stimulation a nursing baby would provide. It’s also compatible with all Philips Avent bottles.

The Best Breast Pumps $50–$150

What you’ll get at this price point:

  • Affordable electric pumps, mostly double
  • Pumps with a choice of suction modes and pumping styles
  • Entry-level wearable pumps

These breast pumps work best if you’re:

  • A semi-regular pumping parent who doesn’t want to break the bank
  • Looking for an affordable step up from a manual pump
  • Received a pump via your insurance but need a second pump for semi-regular use
  • Want to try out a wearable breast pump without spending hundreds of dollars
  • Extremely affordable
  • Rechargeable battery so you can pump cord-free

User reviews are overwhelmingly positive for this double electric pump that’s about half the price of many similar models. This closed-system pump features four pumping modes and nine levels of suction. Breastfeeding parents rave about the pump’s light weight, wireless capabilities and, of course, the price.

  • Budget-friendly wearable option
  • Snug fit for more efficient pumping + silicone flanges for comfort

If you’re not sure you want to take the plunge into wearables (or simply don’t want to spend hundreds of dollars), the S12 is a good place to start. This wearable pump is completely hands- and wire-free. The motor rests on top, so it’s not as discreet as some other wearables, but the pump has lots of other things going for it like comfortable silicone flanges, reusable six-ounce collection cups and a powerful motor.

Two things to note. Most pumpers find that wearable pumps (and collection cups, too) don’t empty them as well as traditional pumps, so a wearable shouldn’t be your primary pump if you’re pumping more than once or twice a day. And for a different option, check out the Imani i2, another favorite budget-friendly wearable.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Three pumping styles and eight suction levels
  • Backlit LCD display
  • ComfortFit flanges designed for extra comfort

A leading name in breastfeeding products, it’s no surprise that this pump from Lansinoh is a popular choice for nursing parents. It’s compatible with other Lansinoh breastfeeding products—a big plus—and offers multiple suction levels and dishwasher-safe parts. It also remembers your settings after each pump and connects to an app to track your sessions, two nice pros, especially at this price point. Some cons include poor battery life and a lower suction strength than some pumping parents would like.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Can independently control suction on each pump side
  • Cordless and rechargeable
  • Comfortable silicone breast shields

There’s a lot to love about this pump from Crane, especially at this price point. This closed-system pump runs on a rechargeable battery, so you’ll be able to pump without being plugged in if you’d like. You can also control each side independently, a nice perk if you like a different suction strength on each side. Other things to love include comfy silicone flanges, nine stimulation and nine expression levels, a compact design and an easy-to-operate control panel.

  • Lightweight and portable
  • Multiple power sources: plug, battery or car adapter
  • Quiet

This double electric option from Evenflo is another good pump choice in this budget-friendly category. It offers multiple suction levels and comes with several flange sizes so you can get the correct—and the most comfortable—fit. The pump works with multiple power sources (including a battery option for cord-free pumping) and is designed to be 50% quieter than other similar breast pumps.

The Best Breast Pumps $150–$250

What you’ll get at this price point:

  • Sweet spot for the most highly rated and the most popular double electric pumps
  • Powerful, efficient suction with customizable settings
  • Accessories like a tote or milk storage container
  • Portable pumps: the power of a traditional pump in a more compact package

These breast pumps work best if you’re:

  • An exclusive pumper
  • Frequently alternating between breast and bottle
  • A working parent who is regularly away from your baby and needs to express milk throughout the day or night
  • Want the suction and output of a traditional without the bulk
Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Hospital-grade
  • Quiet
  • Rechargeable battery lasts up to three hours

Spectra’s S1 is a hospital-grade pump—that means it’s better at fully emptying your breast than some less powerful (and less expensive) breast pumps. The best features of the S1 include portability (the rechargeable battery boasts up to about three hours of cord-free pumping time), an ultra-quiet motor and plenty of massage and suction settings so you can find the custom setting that works best for you. If you’re willing to sacrifice portability, check out the Spectra S2 Plus—it’s about $30 cheaper and just as strong, but it needs to be plugged into the wall at all times.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Sleek, compact design and rechargeable battery for portability
  • Quiet motor

Similar to the Spectra, Luna’s double pump is a powerful, hospital-grade pump with lots of customization options that runs on a rechargeable battery for portability. This closed-system pump boasts a quiet motor and several helpful features like auto shut-off, a built-in nightlight and backlit LCD screen, single or double pumping options and lots more.

  • Small, portable and powerful
  • 14 different suction settings

This buzzworthy pump is smaller than your smartphone—but doesn’t sacrifice at all on suction. Landing somewhere between a traditional closed-system pump and a completely hands-free option, it’s small enough to hold in one hand and light and compact enough to slip into your pocket or wear around your neck while you pump. It features single or double pump capabilities and nine levels of powerful suction (some pumping parents even say it can be too powerful) and runs on a rechargeable battery.

  • Gentler but strong suction
  • Super portable; weighs about half a pound

Another powerful portable, the Genie Advanced from Pumpables offers gentler suction than the Baby Buddha but is still strong enough to function as a primary breast pump. It weight about half a pound and you’ll get four hours of pumping time with each charge. You can also hack it to work with either traditional flanges or collection cups.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Perfect for pumping on the go or at work
  • Includes tote and accessories

The Pump in Style is a great choice for any pumping parent, but especially if you’re working and need to pump at the office. This double electric pump works with a power adapter or with batteries and comes with everything you need including a cooler bag, carry bag, battery pack and lots more.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Portable but powerful
  • Rechargeable battery

Spectra makes some of our favorite high-quality pumps. The 9 Plus is one of their most portable models, weighing in at about half a pound. It’s battery operated for cord-free pumping convenience, features several massage and expression modes and has an easy-to-read LED screen.

The Best Breast Pumps $250 and Up

What you’ll get at this price point:

  • Incredible portability
  • Discreet, wearable pumps
  • Latest breast pump technology and app compatibility

These breast pumps work best if you’re:

  • An exclusive pumper looking too add a portable option in addition to your primary pump
  • Need a discreet way to pump
  • A frequent pumping parent who has the budget for a more expensive pump
Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Wearable, discreet pumping
  • 45° of leak-proof mobility
  • Pump up to 7 oz on each side into reusable milk storage containers

This wearable pump sits at a more affordable price point than other top-tier wearables but performs just as well (and according to some pumpers, even better). It fits right into your bra for hands-free pumping. There are two modes—stimulation and expression—and nine different suction settings. Milk is collected into reusable storage containers so you won’t have to deal with buying disposable bags, and you’ll get about five pumping sessions without having to recharge the battery. The pump comes with five-ounce containers, but you can purchase seven-ounce ones if you need more storage.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Wearable, hands-free pumping
  • Almost completely silent
  • Pump into attached storage bottles—no bags required

The Elvie slips right inside your nursing bra with no tubes or wires. It’s completely silent and has seven different suction settings, including a stimulation setting. Each side holds up to five ounces of expressed milk, suction automatically pauses when milk reaches the top and it’s easy to track your pumping sessions with the Elvie app.

Did you know that insurance will cover all or most of your breast pump?

  • Can control the suction on each side independently
  • Quiet and powerful

Spectra’s most advanced breast pump has the same powerful suction as the brand’s popular S1 and S2 models, but with one extra feature: dual settings that allow for independent suction on each side. It’s a nice plus if you prefer each side of your pump at different settings. Other features include a touch screen LCD with timer, a three-level nightlight and an extremely quiet motor. This model is portable and rechargeable.

This information is provided for educational and entertainment purposes only. We do not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss or risk, personal or otherwise, incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from any information or advice contained here. Babylist may earn compensation from affiliate links in this content. Learn more about how we write Babylist content and review products, as well as the Babylist Health Advisory Board.